journal

Industrial Alcohol industries intoxicating Liqour

Analysis

Whose power is it anyway?

Justice Nagarathna’s dissents in two recent Constitution Bench matters may suggest that achieving ‘federal balance’ is a delicate thing

Gauri Kashyap

28th Oct 2024

More
states power to regulate industrial alcohol

Analysis

Supreme Court to decide states’ power to regulate industrial alcohol

The judgement is expected to settle the turf war between Union and states, with implications on revenue and public health regulation

Gauri Kashyap

22nd Oct 2024

More
bench sizes

Analysis

The large and small of it: the Supreme Court on bench sizes

Two recent dissents raised the question about smaller benches referring matters to larger benches. We look at the Court’s jurisprudence.

Kevin Sebastian

27th Aug 2024

More
cases

Analysis

Which Constitution Bench judgements can we expect in the second half of 2024?

Before the Chief retires, benches led by him must deliver verdicts in cases about citizenship, reservation, tax, minority status and more

R. Sai Spandana and Shubh Naik

5th Jul 2024

More
Article 31C

Analysis

The effect of striking down a substitution: The Article 31C story

A recent hearing brought a crucial constitutional question to the fore—is the original provision revived when an amendment is struck down?

Neha Vinod

25th May 2024

More

Channel

State Governments’ Power to Regulate Industrial Alcohol

In April 2024, the top Court heard 6 days of arguments on states and the Union government's power to regulate Industrial Alcohol

Gauri Kashyap

13th May 2024

More

Analysis

Money matters are the oldest matters

Oil companies, realtors and big business have a lot riding on the outcomes of the three longest-pending nine-judge bench cases

Sushovan Patnaik

4th Mar 2024

More

Analysis

Monthly Review: October 2023

October saw the marriage equality judgement, revival of seven-judge benches, Justice Bhat’s retirement and more

Ayra Kamal

3rd Nov 2023

More

Analysis

The “disproportionate” power of the Chief Justice of India

The “first among equals” may enjoy more powers than what meets the eye. Check out what Dr. Aparna Chandra has to say

SCO Team

27th Oct 2023

More

Analysis

Listing dates for upcoming seven and nine-judge bench cases

The Court is expected to hear all seven and nine-judge matters in the first quarter of 2024.

SCO Team

25th Oct 2023

More
9 Judge Bench Supreme Court

Analysis

What cases will be heard by the nine-judge bench of the Supreme Court?

The nine-judge bench will hear cases on rights of landowners, taxation, power of the state to levy excise fee and industrial disputes

Sushovan Patnaik

12th Oct 2023

More

cases

State of Uttar Pradesh v Lalta Prasad Vaish

In a 8:1 majority, the Supreme Court overturned Sythentics and Chemicals (1990) which held that “intoxicating liquor” under Entry 8 of the State List referred only to potable liquor, taking it our of the scope of states’ powers

More

Mineral Area Development Authority v Steel Authority of India

In a 8:1 majority, a nine-judge Constitution Bench held that state government's can impose tax on mines and minerals. It observed that "royalty" is distinct from tax.

More