journal

dissents

Analysis

The top 7 dissents of Justice D.Y. Chandrachud

Here’s a list of 7 occasions when the outgoing Chief Justice diverged from the majority on conclusion or reasoning during his long tenure

Sushovan Patnaik

8th Nov 2024

More
mineral

Analysis

‘Race to the bottom’: The possible consequences of the mineral royalty judgement

The retrospective application of the decision to allow states to tax mines and minerals could have first- and second-order economic impacts

M. Jannani

23rd Aug 2024

More
reservations

Analysis

Reservations and sub-classification of SC/STs: A mixed bag for substantive equality

The Court settles doubts around ‘efficiency’ as a limitation to reservations, but its approach to methodology & creamy layer raise questions

Anup Surendranath

22nd Aug 2024

More
sub-classification

Analysis

Carving out a new quota

While upholding sub-classification for the SC/ST categories, the Court noted that there are varying degrees of backwardness within the group

Advay Vora

5th Aug 2024

More
revenue

Analysis

A new avenue for state revenue

A nine-judge bench in one of the longest pending cases confirmed that only states have the power to tax mineral-bearing land

R. Sai Spandana

28th Jul 2024

More
Chief

Analysis

The Chief in the minority: Why does this matter?

DESK BRIEF: Since 1950, a Chief Justice has dissented all of 13 times in a Constitution Bench case

Gauri Kashyap

21st Oct 2023

More