journal

dissents

Analysis

The top 7 dissents of Justice D.Y. Chandrachud

Here’s a list of 7 occasions when the outgoing Chief Justice diverged from the majority on conclusion or reasoning during his long tenure

Sushovan Patnaik

8th Nov 2024

More
Industrial Alcohol industries intoxicating Liqour

Analysis

Whose power is it anyway?

Justice Nagarathna’s dissents in two recent Constitution Bench matters may suggest that achieving ‘federal balance’ is a delicate thing

Gauri Kashyap

28th Oct 2024

More
mineral

Analysis

‘Race to the bottom’: The possible consequences of the mineral royalty judgement

The retrospective application of the decision to allow states to tax mines and minerals could have first- and second-order economic impacts

M. Jannani

23rd Aug 2024

More
reservations

Analysis

Reservations and sub-classification of SC/STs: A mixed bag for substantive equality

The Court settles doubts around ‘efficiency’ as a limitation to reservations, but its approach to methodology & creamy layer raise questions

Anup Surendranath

22nd Aug 2024

More
revenue

Analysis

A new avenue for state revenue

A nine-judge bench in one of the longest pending cases confirmed that only states have the power to tax mineral-bearing land

R. Sai Spandana

28th Jul 2024

More

Channel

SCO Explains: A Chief Justice in the minority: Why does this matter?

15% of dissents by a Chief Justice in a Constitution Bench were in the last two years alone. What does this mean?

Gauri Kashyap

25th Oct 2023

More
Chief

Analysis

The Chief in the minority: Why does this matter?

DESK BRIEF: Since 1950, a Chief Justice has dissented all of 13 times in a Constitution Bench case

Gauri Kashyap

21st Oct 2023

More