Tushar Kohli
Tushar Kohli's Posts
Analysis
Five election-related cases in the Court’s docket in the run-up to the 2024 polls
The what, when and why of the top court’s decisions in these key cases could have significant ramifications on India’s electoral landscape
Analysis
More listing trouble in SC as Adani seeks review of electricity dispute through miscellaneous application; judgement reserved
In August 2020, the top court granted compensation to Adani Power but held that the Discom is not liable to pay the surcharge
Analysis
“The SC was set up as a bulwark against injustice, tyranny, arbitrariness”: CJI
At an event to inaugurate the 75th year of the top court, CJI Chandrachud stressed on the Court’s achievements
Analysis
“Complex articulation often seeps into our judgements”: Justice Sanjiv Khanna
While delivering the inaugural address at an event to kick off the Court’s 75th year, the judge acknowledged that orders need to be brief
Hearing Reports
Extension of Border Security Forces Jurisdiction in Punjab | Day 1: Court frames issues
The Court will examine whether the Union interfered with the state’s legislative powers by extending the BSF’s jurisdiction in the state
Analysis
Supreme Court takes stock of virtual hearing systems in High Courts
The top court encouraged the standardisation of virtual hearing procedures across the country’s High Courts
Analysis
Monthly Review: December 2023
December saw the Article 370 judgement, hearings against Section 6A of the Citizenship Act, Justice Kaul’s retirement and more.
Hearing Reports
State-Wise Grant of Minority Status | Day 6: Supreme Court gives a last chance to states to file reports and replies
Irked by delays in filing a response since 2020, the Court warned parties that any further delays will attract a fine of ₹10,000
Analysis
Supreme Court Review 2023: Constitution Bench Decisions
The Supreme Court delivered 18 Constitution Bench decisions in 2023. SCO lists them all
Hearing Reports
AMU Minority Status | Day 1: Existence of central law no bar to minority status, petitioners argue
The petitioners claimed that while AMU has a secular education system, it retains a “Muslim character”
Analysis
Time limit to fill casual vacancies: Supreme Court considers forming guidelines for Election Commission
The Court set aside a Bombay High Court direction to hold the election to replace Late Member of Parliament Girish Bapat immediately.
Analysis
2023 Supreme Court Review: Federalism
In two Constitution Bench cases, the Court clarified centre-state relationships in an asymmetric federal structure
Analysis
Adani-Hindenburg Controversy | Judgement Pronouncement
The Court refused to transfer SEBI’s probe into Adani’s stock manipulation and accounting fraud to the CBI or a Special Investigation Team
Analysis
Supreme Court Review 2023: On Marriage
The SC said marriage age and rights of sexual minorities was in parliament‘s domain. It used its wide powers under Art. 142 to grant divorce
Analysis
Supreme Court passes directions to secure places of worship in Manipur
Manipur Government to inform the Expert Committee on steps for securing vandalised places of worship.
Hearing Reports
Judicial Vacancies in Lower Courts | Day 7: Supreme Court takes note of status report on Delhi’s judicial infrastructure
Status report provides assurances on tender allocation and reveals the extent of deficiency of houses for judges
Analysis
Validity of automatic vacation of stay | Supreme Court reserves judgement
Automatic vacation of stay is arbitrary, judgement in Asian Resurfacing was wrong, SG Mehta argues
Hearing Reports
Validity of automatic vacation of stay: Day 1 | Supreme Court reserves judgement
Automatic vacation of stay is arbitrary, judgement in Asian Resurfacing was wrong, Solicitor General Tushar Mehta argues
Hearing Reports
Section 6A of the Citizenship Act | Day 4: Supreme Court reserves judgement
SG Mehta submits updated data on citizenships and foreigners detected in Assam under Section 6A
Hearing Reports
Judicial Vacancies in Lower Courts | Day 6: Supreme Court questions Delhi government on delay in disbursement of funds for judicial infrastructure
The Supreme Court directed the Government of NCTD to apprise the court of the sanctions for approved projects
Hearing Reports
Sec. 6A of the Citizenship Act | Day 3: Court directs Union government to submit data on number of citizenships granted to immigrants
The Union government asserted that the parliament is constitutionally empowered to make specific citizenship laws
Hearing Reports
Sec. 6A of the Citizenship Act | Day 2: The immigration issue persists in other border states, not just Assam, petitioners argue
Petitioners contended that the provision violates Article 14 by creating an unreasonable classification for Assam among states
Hearing Reports
Sec. 6A of the Citizenship Act | Day 1: People of Assam should not be reduced to a minority, petitioners argue
Senior Advocate Shyam Divan argued that Assam’s resources was unfairly burdened by unfettered immigration from Bangladesh