Satya Prasoon

Satya Prasoon's Posts

Analysis

A Missed Opportunity: Vinod Dua’s Sedition Case

The Court quashed an FIR filed against journalist Vinod Dua and held that there was no incitement to violence and hence it was not sedition.

Analysis

2019 Summer Session Review

During the summer session, the Court delivered various important judgments and responded to disputes arising out of the general elections.

Analysis

Rafale Review Explained

An explainer on the submissions in the Rafale Deal case

Analysis

Supreme Court Cases in the BJP & INC 2019 Manifestos

In this table, a summary of the status of each case, what the Supreme Court has held, and what the BJP and INC promise.

Analysis

Electoral Bond Scheme: Where do the ADR, EC & Union stand on the issue?

The Supreme Court is hearing the electoral bonds case. Here are the positions of the parties.

Analysis

2 Judges recommended by collegium for Supreme Court elevation

The Supreme Court Collegium has recommended the elevation of Jharkhand HC CJ Anirudha Bose and Gauhati HC CJ AS Bopanna to the Supreme Court

Analysis

2019 Spring Session Review

The Court's Spring Session saw decisions on the CBI dispute, the validity of the IBC, and the Maharashtra Bar Dancers case, among others.

Analysis

Supreme Court in the Classroom: Worksheet 3

This worksheet tasks students with understanding how the Supreme Court balances reservation in promotion with equality and efficiency.

Analysis

SC Sets Up In-House Think Tank

Centre for Research and Planning, an "in-house think tank" has been established by Ranjan Gogoi CJI.

Analysis

Four Judges elevated to Supreme Court

Justices Shah, Gupta, Rastogi, and Reddy have been sworn in as judges of the Supreme Court of India

Analysis

Monthly Review: October 2018

In October, CJI Gogoi has prioritized administrative efficiency and filling judicial vacancies

Analysis

Ayodhya Title Dispute: 3 Cases that have Shaped the Dispute

A look at three important cases which have influenced the Ayodhya title dispute.

Analysis

Timeline: Key Events in the Babri Masjid – Ram Mandir Controversy

Tracing the timeline of key events in the Babri Masjid- Ayodhya Title Dispute Case.

Analysis

Decriminalisation of Section 377: 5 Must Reads

Here are some must-reads on the decriminalisation of Section 377

Analysis

Constitutionality of Aadhaar: 6 Must Reads

Here are some must-reads on the constitutionality of Aadhaar

Analysis

Review Petitions in Sabarimala

19 review petitions filed against Sabarimala judgment challenging jurisdiction of the Court and claiming that the Petitioners had no locus.

Analysis

2018 Monsoon Session Review

Supreme Court Observer reviews the monsoon session of the Supreme Court, identifies key trends, and revisits important judgments

Analysis

Electoral Disqualification: 2 Must Reads

Here are some must-reads on electoral disqualification

Analysis

Sabarimala Temple Entry Case: 4 Must Reads

4 articles which conclusively examine the Supreme Courts Sabarimala Verdict.

Analysis

Decriminalisation of Adultery: 3 Must Reads

Here are some must-reads on the decriminalisation of adultery

Analysis

Reservation in Promotion: 3 Must Reads

Three articles analysing the verdict of the Court regarding reservation in promotion.

Analysis

Defining Dignity

Pritam Baruah and Vikram Aditya Narayan argue that the concept of dignity suffers from "legal indeterminacy"

Analysis

Monthly Review: September 2018

CJI Gogoi has signalled that his main aim is to improve the administrative efficiency of the judiciary.

Analysis

Week Ahead: Supreme Court, Sept 10-14 2018

What lies ahead this week in the Supreme Court?

Analysis

Monthly Review: August 2018

In August, the Court reserved judgment in casers on adultery law, reservation in promotion and the criminalisation of politics.

Analysis

Monthly Review: July 2018

In July, the Court formed constitution benches in many cases and heard Section 377 and Sabarimala cases  

Analysis

WhatsApp and lynchings

Various experts discuss the culpability of WhatsApp for recent lynching incidents

Analysis

Let’s All Go to the Temple

Vaishna Roy argues that religious customs which perpetuate social discrimination should not be given constitutional sanction

Analysis

Justice Goel – A Judicial Portrait

Justice Goel's tenure was marked by some key judgments in the field of criminal law, including the much-criticized Kashinath Mahajan case

Analysis

2018 Monsoon Session Preview

The Court will hear three important constitutional cases in the first week and deliver judgments in the NCT Case and in Puttaswamy

Analysis

Justice J. Chelameswar – A Judicial Portrait

The rich legacy left behind by Chelameswar J includes multiple landmark precedents ranging from NJAC to electoral disqualifications.

Analysis

Monthly Review: May 2018

In May, the Court saw Justice Joseph's Elevation and hearings in the Aadhaar, CJI Impeachment, Rohingya Deportation, and Ayodhya cases

Analysis

Karnataka Election Case: Arguments

The Court resumed hearings in the Karnataka Election Case, with Mr. Mukul Rohatgi on one side and Mr. Abhishek Manu Singhvi on the other

Analysis

Karnataka Election Case Explained

An in-depth analysis of the challenge to the Karnataka Legislative Assembly Election results.

Analysis

Gary Jeffrey Jacobsohn – Constitutional Principles in India: Context, Text and Subtext

Gary Jacobsohn analyses the 2017 judgment in Abhiram Singh v Commachen Case

Analysis

Pratik Datta, Shefali Malhotra & Shivangi Tyagi, Judicial Review and Money Bill (NUJS Law Review)

This paper in the NUJS Law Review looks at Article 110 to clarify the legal provision on the judicial review of a money bill certification

Analysis

Rajeev Dhavan: Encoding Secularism in Law

Rajeev Dhavan critiques the Faruqui judgment of 1994 which upheld the land acquisition of Babri land by Central Government

Analysis

Government’s flip-flop on the Aadhaar-SIM linking issue before the Supreme Court

Roham Venkaramakrishnan writes the government's defence rests on shaky ground

Analysis

Monthly Review: April 2018

April saw the appointment of Justice Indu Malhotra, an impeachment motion against the CJI, and consequential developments in important cases

Analysis

Monthly Review: March 2018

March saw three key judgments delivered, while the cracks within the Supreme Court became visible on more than one occasion.

Analysis

Aadhaar: Analysis of first 13 days

This post reviews the key arguments and postulations raised by three counsels - Sr. Advs. Shyam Divan, Kapil Sibal, and Gopal Subramanium

Analysis

Ayodhya: Role of The Supreme Court

The Court has continued to manage the conflict by directing the case to come up as a title dispute, a narrow legal facet of the case

Analysis

Interview with Indira Jaising – Triple Talaq

Sr. Adv. Indira Jaising represented Bebaak Collective and was instrumental in convincing the court to strike down Triple Talaq

Analysis

Interview with Kapil Sibal (Pt.1) – Triple Talaq

Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal was the arguing counsel in two landmark judgments in 2017 – Triple Talaq and Privacy

Analysis

Interview with Anand Grover (Pt.2) – Right to Privacy

The Supreme Court Observer spoke to Senior Advocate Anand Grover, who was one of the arguing counsels in the Triple Talaq case

Analysis

Interview with Anand Grover (Pt.1) – Triple Talaq

The Supreme Court Observer spoke to Senior Advocate Anand Grover, who was one of the arguing counsels in the Triple Talaq case